Plain Boxes vs Printed Boxes: Which Is Best for Your Business?

For many businesses, packaging is simply viewed as a way to protect products during transit.

However, every box you send also represents an opportunity to promote your brand, improve customer experience and create a more professional impression.

The question many businesses ask is:

Should we continue using plain boxes, or is it time to invest in printed packaging?

The answer depends on your products, customers and business objectives.

In this guide, we'll compare plain and printed boxes, explore the costs and benefits of each, and explain when printed packaging can become a worthwhile investment.

In Short: Plain or Printed Boxes?

Both plain and printed boxes have their place.

Choose plain boxes if you:

• Require maximum flexibility
• Ship products for multiple brands
• Need smaller production runs
• Frequently change packaging designs

Consider printed boxes if you:

• Want to strengthen your brand
• Ship directly to customers
• Send high volumes of products
• Want a more professional appearance
• Are looking to improve customer experience

For many growing businesses, printed packaging offers benefits that extend well beyond the cost of the box itself.

What Is the Difference Between Plain and Printed Boxes?

A plain corrugated box provides reliable protection without printed branding.

A printed corrugated box includes your company branding, logo, messaging or graphics directly on the packaging.

Printing can range from a simple one-colour logo through to more detailed designs depending on your branding requirements.

Both options provide the same protective function, but the customer experience can be very different.

The Benefits of Plain Boxes

Plain boxes remain the right choice for many businesses.

Advantages include:

• Lower initial cost
• Suitable for multiple product lines
• Easy to order in smaller quantities
• Flexible for changing requirements
• Fast production times

For businesses shipping wholesale products or internal goods, plain boxes may continue to be the most practical option.

The Benefits of Printed Boxes

Printed packaging offers much more than visual appeal.

Strengthen Your Brand

Every shipment arriving at a customer's premises becomes an advertisement for your business.

A professionally printed box reinforces your brand before the customer even opens the package.

Consistent branding helps improve recognition and creates a more memorable customer experience.

Create a Professional First Impression

Customers often judge a business within seconds of receiving a delivery.

A well-presented printed box communicates professionalism, quality and attention to detail.

This can be particularly valuable for:

• E-commerce retailers
• Subscription businesses
• Premium products
• Gift items
• Direct-to-consumer brands

Improve the Unboxing Experience

The popularity of social media and online reviews has increased the importance of packaging presentation.

Printed packaging can enhance the overall customer experience and help create a positive first impression that encourages repeat business.

Reduce the Need for Additional Labels

Many businesses use adhesive labels or stickers to identify products or reinforce branding.

In some cases, printed packaging can reduce or eliminate these additional steps, improving packing efficiency while creating a cleaner finished appearance.

Is Printed Packaging More Expensive?

This is probably the biggest misconception surrounding printed packaging.

Many businesses assume printed boxes are significantly more expensive than plain boxes.

In reality, the difference is often much smaller than expected, particularly when ordering larger quantities.

Once printing set-up costs are spread across higher production volumes, the additional cost per box can become surprisingly low.

For businesses ordering packaging regularly, printed boxes can represent excellent value.

Why Ordering Larger Quantities Can Save Money

Packaging production becomes more efficient as order quantities increase.

Larger production runs can reduce:

• Machine setup time per box
• Production costs
• Transport costs per unit
• Ordering frequency
• Administrative time

This means the cost per box often decreases as order quantities increase.

For businesses with predictable packaging requirements, ordering in larger batches can provide significant long-term savings.

When Printed Boxes Make Financial Sense

Printed packaging is often worth considering if you:

• Ship products directly to customers
• Send hundreds or thousands of parcels each year
• Want stronger brand recognition
• Attend trade shows or exhibitions
• Sell premium products
• Want your packaging to reflect the quality of your products

When viewed as both protective packaging and a marketing tool, printed boxes can deliver value beyond their manufacturing cost.

Plain Boxes Still Have Their Place

Printed packaging is not always the best solution.

Plain boxes continue to offer excellent value for businesses that:

• Package products for multiple customers
• Frequently change product ranges
• Require maximum flexibility
• Order smaller quantities
• Prioritise functionality over branding

Choosing the right packaging is about selecting the option that best supports your business objectives.

The Right Box Is More Than Just Printing

Whether you choose plain or printed packaging, the box still needs to perform its primary function.

The correct packaging should provide:

• The right dimensions
• Appropriate board strength
• Reliable product protection
• Efficient storage
• Cost-effective shipping

Good packaging begins with good design.

How ASC Direct Can Help

At ASC Direct, we supply both plain and printed corrugated packaging designed around your products and your business.

Whether you're looking for cost-effective plain boxes or professionally printed packaging that enhances your brand, we can help you choose the most appropriate solution.

Our team can also advise on production quantities, helping you balance flexibility, cost and branding to achieve the best value for your business.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are printed boxes worth the extra cost?

For many businesses, yes. Printed boxes can strengthen brand recognition, improve customer experience and provide a more professional appearance. When ordered in suitable quantities, the additional cost per box is often lower than many businesses expect.

Are plain boxes cheaper than printed boxes?

Plain boxes usually have a lower initial unit cost. However, as production quantities increase, the cost difference between plain and printed boxes often becomes much smaller.

Can printed packaging improve customer experience?

Yes. Professionally branded packaging creates a stronger first impression and can help customers perceive your business as more professional and established.

Can I order printed boxes in bulk?

Yes. Ordering larger quantities often reduces the cost per box by spreading production setup costs across the entire order, making printed packaging a more economical option.

Which is best for my business?

The right choice depends on your products, order volumes, branding objectives and budget. Many businesses find that printed packaging provides long-term value by combining product protection with brand promotion.

James Palfrey-Smith is the General Manager at ASC Direct with extensive experience in both operations and sales. James is passionate about solving packaging problems, delivering fast customer support, and building lasting relationships. Outside of work, he enjoys outdoor activities like hiking and skiing. A fan of real ale and business podcasts, he continuously seeks personal and professional growth. 

Find James on  Linkedin 

Find out more about James